AI replacing programmers
Introduction
The AI hype brings w/ it, among many annoying tropes, the “programmers will be replaced soon” thesis that never struck me as even remotely accurate.
My perspective may be lacking
- outside any Silicon Valley hype
- as a software engineer in machine manufacturing, where requirements and approaches probably differ from, say, a web startup
- and as a slow and conservative adopter of AI myself (mainly use it as a faster search engine for well-known APIs, specs, standard library functionality)
but here’s why I don’t think I will be replaced soon:
we (humans) don’t want to be replaced
just philosophically, we’re far from giving up too much control when it comes to important use cases. A small flash game for the laughs is one thing, processing sensitive information, heavy machinery, etc are a complete other. We will be slow in giving up too much control, for reasons of simple human nature (skepticism of the new) to completely valid concerns, e.g. of having AI build monsters of complexity that will crumble without us being able to grasp them anymore
w/ AI humans will become worse at programming, accelerating AI need
maybe only tangentially related to the replacement thesis, but something I wanted to address regardless. As with anything, it’s a tool. Just as you can use your phone for brainrot short-form video content, you can also use it to read books and learn a language between commutes. It’s in the use, not the technology itself. As much as AI might make some programmers worse, it will mostly accelerate the learning of people who use it well, just as the internet itself does.
we aren’t peak code quantity
If we end up being more productive due to AI we’ll end up writing more code (we aren’t peak code)! “You’re 10 times more productive due to AI now, you’re fired”. If that was the case I’d happily pack my bags. If what I do simply isn’t a productive win for anyone to pay me, I’m happy to be productive in other ways, but it doesn’t really compute… will companies justify layoffs due to AI? Probably, will it be truly due to AI? Probably not.
And just to be clear, I even doubt the 10x gain, I’m saying “even if”.
we aren’t peak code quality
If AI helps us write better code… great, software all over is in an abysmal state in many respects. Before layoffs we have a lot to fix and put on more solid footing than it is at the moment…
code is design, not math
code isn’t purely mathematical, it’s a design decision w/ tradeoffs each step of the way. I don’t see how you even could give AI full control. I can’t imagine AI on a complicated problem without a human in the loop. W/ more & more complex software such design decisions, and the ability to understand and debug the code, become even more important, not less!
programs encode human requirements
Software is used for companies’ processes & products to interact and communicate with each other, those specifications are carefully managed by people on both ends, at the end is a human operator wanting to use software or processed results. I have trouble seeing much potential for replacement. In the end we’re working for each other, which will continue. To put the human ‘out of loop’ in this regard would be to put the human out of the loop almost anywhere else in life, too. Even if you believe this, then programming is in no way in any ‘special’ danger, just in as much as anything else.
code is not the work
code is part of a programmer’s work, but not the work. Project management, time estimates, communication between in-house technical crafts that need to play together, customer relations, commissioning & servicing, documentation, social engineering your way to needed information (in a non-bad way), debugging in far more ways than purely the software, and then comes the code itself. The context management for all of what’s involved is outside any AI in so many ways I can’t even begin to spell it out.
so in closing…
There’ll be more than enough jobs for programmers… for a lifetime to come I figure! Maybe the odd web designer will indeed be ‘rationalized away’, but be competent in a technical niche, and I don’t think one has to worry. Absurdly, I even consider it possible we’ll end up needing more of them, not fewer.
Merry Christmas!